Intelligent, Informed, Independent and (occasionally) Irreverent

White Hat
- Curated Content
Constantly updated
Simple ingredients
- simply cooked
Suits all tastes
Fresh produce
- Locally sourced
Direct from the grower
White Hat
- Recipes and tips
Join our newsletter

Skip Navigation LinksHome > The White Hat Cookbook > Recipes > Potato Salad

The White Hat Guide to

Potato Salad

Potato Salad

Recipes and tips

The White Potato Salad

South of the Murray Potato Salad

Potato salad

There are only two ingredients you need to get right for Potato salad. The potatoes and the mayonnaise.

Those of you who live north of the Murray can stop reading now because it is not in your genetic makeup to understand either.

For those of you who live south of the Murray and are just about to take a pre-packaged potato salad off the supermarket shelf, just pause for a minute. After Australia’s first mineral boom the landscape was left devastated - vast amounts of vegetation had been chopped down and the creeks were muddied and polluted. All that was left in many cases was dirt. The goldrush had laid waste vast areas of land between Melbourne and the Grampians leaving mainly dirt. You could run a few sheep on it perhaps, but it was mainly dirt.

There - bend down and taste it - it’s dirt.

Several at the time did bend down and taste it and could immediately tell it was dirt - not your ordinary north-of-the-Murray sandy loam but proper chocolate dirt. The volcanic activity in the Gariwerd region about 10 million years ago had generated lava that flowed east as far as the current path of the Yarra. That volcanic soil had broken down over the centuries into soil that was ideal for - potatoes!

Of course potatoes aren’t just potatoes. Anyone who has grown up in somewhere like Ballarat can tell the difference between a Bunninyong potato, a Trentham potato and a Clarkes Hill potato - provided you don’t scrape all the dirt off before the taste test. The only other people in Australia who understand potatoes are Tasmanians which sort of makes them honorary Victorians except they colonised us first but it all works out in the mash. For your proper South of the Murray Potato Salad you need the right potatoes - not the disintegrating floury ones from last night’s tea - if you have to recycle them, call it leftovers but not potato salad. They will end up tasting like the stuff you get from the fridge in chicken shops or in 5 star hotels on the Gold Coast -

’How did you find the steak sir?’
’It was a bit of a challenge, but eventually I scraped off the fruit salad and there it was,’
’And what about the potato salad?’
(You decide the least said the soonest forgotten.)

What you need is a firm potato that won’t lose its shape - most finger shaped potatoes fit the bill but you can find a brief rundown of the types of potato available in Australia.

The other key ingredient is the mayonnaise which is easy enough when you make your own - you do make your own don’t you? Neither do we most of the time but there are two alternatives. The first is to buy one of the better versions from the supermarket. It will almost certainly be too sweet in the fast food fashion but it can be wrangled into an acceptable shape. Thin it out with some sour cream and cut through the sickly sweetness by adding some lemon juice. It’s not great but it’s a darned sight better than what you started with.

The second (and preferable) option for mayonnaise is to visit Herr and Frau Gruenewald down the street. You explain that you are about to make some mayonnaise for a potato salad but you have forgotten the proportions. Frau Gruenewald tuts that you really should take notes while Herr Gruenewald reappears with glasses of schnapps all round. When quizzed about what dill cucumber you will be using in your potato salad and your answer of ones from a supermarket in a jar does not seem to measure up to the mark, Fraulein Gruenewald is dispatched to fetch some home-made ones.

Dill cucmber

After the third glass of schnapps Frau Gruenewald has made up a batch of mayonnaise using eggs from the chooks outside and enquires whether you have remembered the proportions. You nod unconvincingly and return home with dill pickle and mayonnaise worthy of your South of the Murray Potato Salad. If you don’t have a Herr and Frau Gruenewald in your street you really ought to consider moving.

Now it is time to start putting everything together. Put your potatoes in a saucepan of water and bring to the boil. Simmer until semi-cooked so that a knife will slide in reasonably easily. When using ’finger’ potatoes we prefer to cook them whole and then cut them up when they have cooled. Meanwhile in a frypan gently fry some bacon cubes in a little olive oil together with garlic and sliced red onion until they have softened. Transfer the bacon, onion and garlic together with the pan juices into a bowl then add the drained and sliced warm potatoes. Allow the potatoes to soak up some of the juices and once cooled to near room temperature add the mayonnaise (we prefer to add some mustard or horseradish to the mayonnaise) chopped mint, parsley and dill (or whatever green herb you have available), sliced dill cucumbers and capers. Finally add some quartered boiled eggs and maybe some prosciutto which has been crisped in a pan and crumbled. We prefer to keep our ingredients large and chunky so that the individual flavours crop up in each mouthful.

And as for you - yes you - the one taking the alleged potato salad off the supermarket shelf - ask the attendant if the potatoes came from Bunninyong, Trentham or Clarkes Hill. If they can’t tell you it’s time to honour your heritage and go home and make a proper South of the Murray Potato Salad.

Potato Salad


“thanks for your potato salad recipe it was beautiful (made with spuds from newlyn )...all the best for the new year cheers sandy (zeerust ,vic.)”

___________________  White Hat  ___________________

Some related articles

Some events and locations related to Potatoes:

Trentham Farmers' Market

Trentham's authentic Farmers Market has a selection of dairy and goats cheeses, fresh honey, eggs and live poultry, preserves, local potatoes and sourdough breads, organic and conventional produce, olive products, plants and fresh flowers, organic and conventional wines and an assortment of natural farm products.

___________________  White Hat  ___________________

Crookwell Potato Festival

Celebrating over 150 years of growing potatoes high on the Southern Tableland of NSW

___________________  White Hat  ___________________
Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter 'Food and Cooking - the White Hat guide'